AJ's OldTown Steakhouse & Tavern

Reviews about AJ's OldTown Steakhouse & Tavern

• 1 / 5

  By Zissou Peacock
  We went there a few weeks ago during a vacation to Alaska. First impressions were good, but then the waiter clearly forgot to put our order in. We waited over a hour for food, as others who got sat after us received theirs. This was brought up to the manager, who assured us forgetfulness was "not the case". Totally unwilling to accept responsibility.
  
  In short, it was made very clear that they don't value customers. This is a high tourist area, and they're clearly not concerned with repeat business. Save yourself the over-priced frustration, and go elsewhere for dinner. Lots of great places to eat in Homer that don't treat you like an expendable commodity.
  May 16, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Jennifer Bradley
  Reasonably priced menu (ranges from $10 salads/ $15-20burgers /$50steak &shrimp), and a lot of selection. The Philly cheese was absolutely delicious, though it had no bell peppers. My family also enjoyed a mini Alfredo, chicken breast sandwich, and an Irish coffee. The staff was pleasant, prompt, and our waitress stopped by enough to make sure our meal was going well. The setting is nice enough to go in business/dress attire, but casual enough where going in jeans doesn't feel uncomfortable. Unobtrusive dim lighting, beautiful artwork on the wall, soft yet catchy music on the stereo, and a rose on every table in the dining section (there is also a tavern/bar section). I would definitely come back.
  March 14, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Sean Sullivan
  Excellent dinner, service, and atmosphere!
  September 26, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By Debbie Spencer
  Known for their steaks, they serve only the best cuts. They serve fresh local seafood. They have a full bar. We always receive great service, we feel like family.
  August 11, 2016